Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. In the meantime, a new theory could finally explain one of the Paramount series most perplexing family mysteries. All too true. In a Reddit thread discussing the topic, one fan poses that Mama Dutton is CRAZY. If you recall, theres a moment from the first season when teenage Beth is riding a horse timidly alongside Kayce and her mom. Why did she even blame her for falling off? That's what Evelyn was trying to teach Beth, to be tough as nails. First - James Dutton. There is no way to recover from that massive of a procedure privately. They reside and grow up on a ranch. She said he didnt know why she couldnt have children. This side shows shes perhaps just trying to teach Beth about the tougher side of living on a ranch rather than just ragging on her for no reason. For all of Beths worship of her father, John Dutton is not (nor has he ever been) known for Danny Tanner-level heart-to-hearts. During a flashback scene, fans found out why Beth hates Jamie so much. Instead of offering comfort, the Dutton mother chastises Beth for being so scared of the animal. Yellowstone has not even allowed Beth to express how she felt beyond her righteous anger over being infertile. The doctor told Beth that she had changed her demeanor after she thanked the OBGYN. Evelyn has briefly appeared throughout the series as a cold-hearted parent to her and John Dutton's (Kevin Costner) only daughter. Jamies real father is a man namedGarrett Randall, who was adopted by John. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Redditor iheartsev agrees that Beths mother seemed way too nasty b****y to her during that last ride with Kayce and Beth. The oldest Dutton sibling (Dave Annabel) died in season 1 during a dispute over cattle. Last episode, the ghost (metaphorical) of Dutton's deceased wife hung over much of the episode, with Beth angered at having to be in the same room as a picture of their family back when it was whole, and . Prior to her death, Beth became nervous on her horse, causing her horse to spook leading to Evelyns horse to spook too. In an interview with actress Kelly Reily, who portrays Beth, she states that We get to see this very pure young girl go through such a trauma. Let her undo it. Beth becomes traumatized by the experience and her mothers harsh dying words. Yellowstone: How Beths Mother Had a Negative Impact on Her Decisions. William Armstrong is a senior editor with H-O-M-E.org, where he writes on a wide variety of topics. Lucille Ball told everyone in Hollywood, when she first arrived, that she was from Butte, Montana. Why is John Dutton's one (and only) daughter, Beth Dutton, so mean? Yet as Redditor AmericanWanderlust cites: Wasnt the mom trying to toughen Beth up? Youre stronger than all of them because if men were responsible for giving birth, the human race wouldnt have lasted two generations., Evelyn is a comforting mother as Beth sits in the bathtub, but she has some more tough words of wisdom for her daughter. I know she's a very popular character, but I feel like she just sucks up the atmosphere on the show. Jamie may be more estranged than ever from the Duttons, but he has something Beth never can a biological child. She lost respect for him after he agreed to the surgery. Its no secret that throughout her appearance in Yellowstone, Beths mother, Evelyn Dutton was tough on her. Was there something I missed that sheds light on this? Beths mother died in a horseback riding accident when Beth was just six years old. Her death also took a considerable toll on her children, especially Beth. The rest of Yellowstone Season 5 could have the answer to that and if Beth can soften her mean streak. So sad. The story goes that. It was the best gift she ever gave me.. Things have arguably grown even more acidic between the siblings in Season 2, with Beth's constant barrage . Whether Jamie is being spiteful to get to Beth or not, his words land, bringing that guilt and anger to the surface, the guilt that others blame her for Evelyn Dutton's death. Now because of that, Evelyn says shell be harder on her so that she can turn Beth into something that most men will never be. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. However, she may have been closer to Kayce than any of her other children, as she was very honest with her and did not shy away from telling her the truth, even if it was difficult. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. It was a time when Beth was a skittish young teen with no self-confidence , which irritated her mother Evelyn (Gretchen Mol). The show has plenty of enigmatic characters, and one that has fans debating is Evelyn Dutton, John Duttons wife. Her immediate impulse upon seeing a woman she doesn't know in nothing but one of her father's shirts (the television world's way of showing that a woman has just had sex) is to threaten her with a. Kayce had a son named Tate who was Jamies nephew. Beths mom was calling her scared and thats what killed her. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. It is that simple to understand. She passed away on March 30th, 1997. Riggins was the man who hired the militia to attack John, Kayce and Beth, as well as the ranch, but his motives are not known. She constantly carries the guilt of the accident even though it was not her fault. But he will be mad at Jamie. Its a storyline Yellowstone would shed significant light on throughout the first three seasons, with flashbacks in Season 3 lending harsh weight specifically to the Beth & Jamie dynamic. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Now, an extreme event like that is just that, a freak event. Lee (Dave Annable) is the oldest son of John and Evelyn Dutton. Not as soon or as certainly as fans once thought. Evelyn said it wasn't going to be easy, that she has to be tough, work harder to outlast her male counterparts in order to survive the dog eat dog world. We're firmly in a hiatus of Dutton family dramathe fifth (super-sized) season of Yellowstone is set to return with more (hopefully not final) episodes this summer, while the new prequel series 1923 is officially coming back for a second seasonbut that doesn't mean our minds aren't still on . This timeline puts Jamie around 20 to 21 when Beth came to him for his discretion and aid with procuring an abortion. As a result, Evelyns horse also got spooked, resulting in her death. Beth even bathes in a trough and drinks champagne on the anniversary of her mothers passing, struggling to cope. Set to premiere on December 19, around midway through the mainline series fourth season run, Y:1883 will star Tim McGraw and Faith Hill as the original Duttons. Hi, loving the series and finished it. Evelyn is a comforting mother as Beth sits in the bathtub, but she has some more tough words of wisdom for her daughter. But as the series has moved along, her hate for him continues to grow more and more intense, and some fans think she's gone overboard. As much as Yellowstone Season 5 sees Beth wrestle with her demons, it also deals Beth her harshest blow. But when her horse got spooked, the animal landed on Evelyn. In one episode, during Evelyns death anniversary, Beth, struggling to cope, bathed in a trough and drank champagne to wash away her guilt. You should try zoomba. However, her appearances have been relegated to flashbacks as Johns wife was crushed to death by her horse in a horrific accident in 1997. And his status or role on the show. There is no reason to believe that Beth underwent hormone replacement therapy. The shows board on the social media platform continues to prompt thought-provoking discussion on our favorite characters. Not too long ago, my grandpa (who is approaching 80) said it was time for my daughter's to start barrel racing. Bethany Dutton, the second youngest child and only daughter to ranch owners John Dutton and Evelyn Dutton. In the last moments of Lee, the brother in Kayces soul wakes up and ties to heal Lee but Lee finally succumbs to the injuries caused to him by the wounds of the bullet. yer its nice for them/us to get the reward in season 3, and to hear kelly reilly talk about it is really interesting. Following her mothers death, Beth starts having a terrible time in life. She is essentially a witch with future seeing abilities. More From. According to Beth, the best of her father died along with her mother. I still am not clear why Beth was hated by her mom. cosmetology continuing education classes near me; tracy and peter palandjian; raspberry roll maneuver; judge jaclyn medina bergen county; hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy sirius cybernetics corporation; Such a sad & heartbreaking story for the whole family especially for Beth who was so young ! After mulling over why everyone hates Jamie as much as they do (again), the Redditor moves to Beths deep emotional scarring by matriarch Evelyn Dutton. Not every character on the show has really done much work on their self. That is one of the big questions that has loomed over the series ever since Season 1. Nope. He has also worked as a radio reporter and holds a degree from Moody College of Communication. In future flashbacks, we know young Beth fools around with Rip, but we don't get a lot more of Evelyn Dutton in the series (thus far). However, this approach backfired, and resulted in Beths mother gettng crushed by a horse. It is known that Beth keeps her sterility from everyone, and it remains the seething secret that understandably destroys her and Jamies relationship forever. When Yellowstone explains how the Duttons were shaped by their matriarch, Evelyn Dutton, it takes viewers back to the past. The son of a ranch owner and his wife is married to another woman. Related: 20 Best Yellowstone Characters Ranked. Related: Evelyn was bucked off her horse as Beth hesitated. He doesnt know that she was pregnant with his child. I think her mom loved her but wanted to make her strong in the town of ranchers and men. Jamies biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. According to the Redditor, their father was Dirk. Rip loves Beth dearly, and he won't be mad at her when he finds out the truth of what happened. My best guess is and I've said it before perhaps Evelyn and John only wanted boys instead of girls, and Evelyn resented having Beth. And while fans seem to have it figured out, we know that Beth was also traumatized by her experience with an abortion as a teen. Iheartsev replies with the perfect answer, however. In season 1, episode 7, The Long Black Day, we see a flashback to the day that Evelyn died. Yellowstone TV: Fans Debate Whether Evelyn Dutton Was Too Hard on Beth, re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn, bottle it up and channel that anger and hurt into strength. When the horse fell on her she straight up told a 10 year old that it was her fault if she died, while basically saying that Kayce was the child she loved most. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. Evelyn Dutton is back again. All those boys you used to outrun and outwrestle, thats all done, Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) says after a young Beth starts her period in this EXCLUSIVE preview of a Yellowstone flashback scene from the Aug. 8 episode. Numerous fans agree that it is great to watch Kelly Reilly as Beth Dutton. Tate was kidnapped at the end of the second season. Evelyn was riding a horse that was spooked by Beths nerves. Beth's unstable emotional state is a result of multiple factors, with her mother being only a piece of the puzzle. Evelyn Dutton clearly loved all of her children deeply. In a post paying tribute to Mols performance in the series, user klaise1 asked: Why does she hate Beth? Theyre going to look at you different, see you different, and theyre going to look at you like youre less, like youre somehow weaker today than you were yesterday. Many of these theories have one thing in common - their mother's death. At the start of the series, the Duttons' hatred for Jamie is not obvious, save for Beth Dutton. Will miss when the series ends ! The appearances of Evelyn we see in Yellowstone are in flashbacks and photos shown of her. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". For example, when the horse fell on her and she was seriously injured, Evelyn told Kayce that it was her fault if she died. Fans of the Yellowstone series are on the edge of their seats as they watch the Dutton family fight to defend their lands. Jamie is not gleeful at the prospect, far from it. Lee Dutton. Her small yet impactful role in the modern Western drama has invariably shown her being tough and callous towards teenage Beth (Kylie Rogers). Now, he is too Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol) #Yellowstone pic.twitter.com/P4Pqjg9yXf. who is the young man that wants Beth to be his mother? Instead of comforting or reassuring Beth, Evelyn immediately blames Beth for spooking her horse due to Beths handling (or lack thereof) of her horse. A past as "broken" as that of the Dutton family would scar anyone for life. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. However, it is Jamies latest betrayal of their father that gives Beth the green light to potentially realize her darkest dream. John Dutton Sr. was a great role model for his son and helped him bcome the man he is today. And for that, we cant fault Yellowstones writers at all. She is the third youngest of the Dutton siblings, with Kayce being the youngest. She was a strong, independent woman who loved her family and her horses. So, how did Evelyn Dutton die? The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. This momentous life event caused Beth to grow up resenting Jamie who didnt tell her in the process of her abortion that she was also being sterilized. Learn More. Home Entertainment 15 Facts About Evelyn Dutton Yellowstone. John was close to Jamies birth mother and he was the father of Jamie. When viewers glimpse Beth in flashbacks during Season 1, it is obvious that Beth was not born with her claws out. UX Design Portfolio. It is unclear when or how Beth eventually learned the truth about her condition. four monks white distilled vinegar sds. Good question. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. I Lov this series Yellowstone its actresses & actors! Monica Long was married to Kayce and they had a son named Tate. Jamies goal in this scenario is two-fold. That's why you're sitting in a bar instead of standing in a river. A longstanding sibling . Guess I kinda just watch the show, watch them all try to co-exist and figure it all out. Not always in that order. Her death had a profound impact on her children and continues to haunt them years later. Fans will have to wait and see if any more flashbacks explain their strained relationship any further, but a new theory has proposed the upcoming Yellowstone prequel could also reveal more. Back then and now, Beth continues to self-medicate with abundant alcohol and cigarette use. She is treating Beth with such disdain because she knows Beth will end up with Rip.. ah, snowflakes isnt just a this generation meme then. I think people narrow Evelyn Dutton down to just Beth, and there is clearly a much bigger story then that. However, fans have another outlook on the relationship. Theyve Had an Inappropriate Relationship For Months, How Black Creators Can Expand Their Network with LinkedIn. What other consequences Evelyns death has for the rest of the family remains to be seen. Beth is being raised on a really large Montana ranch. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. A recent comment on Reddit has explained why the familys origin story could provide some vital background information for Evelyn and Beths feud. She told the 10 year old that it was her fault if she died because she loved Kayce the most. Kevin has always stated that Evelyn was the love of Johns life and even created a song just for her on his Tales from the Yellowstone album, so clearly there was a very deep love and her loss impacted them all very deeply. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men. He never has been fully able to recover from her tragic death. She has more chemistry with him than summer. No wonder Beth is a mess. Yellowstone fans are coming to the Dutton daughters defense after re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn. In Yellowstone Season 3, John finally learns the truth amid Beth and Jamies ever-escalating feud. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. That's one helluva thing to bestow upon a young girl. Fans of Yellowstone discuss in a post why John favors Kayce over Jamie. Conversely, opting to make it all about the other reason Beth is so mean. The Duttons are a pretty evil family. As Yellowstone has moved forward, it has distanced itself from this part of Beths backstory. So I just binged the first three seasons and have a few questions, begins Yellowstone fan tomcookgod over on Reddit. His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. However, he has not remarried yet or had a serious relationship. See, in the 1883 script her side of the family are from Salemyeah, that Salem. John Duttons wife Evelyn Dutton died in a horseback riding accident on March 30, 1997. Because her mom was an ice-cold, manipulating beeyotch. One thing is for sure, John Dutton hasnt moved on after losing his beloved spouse, even after decades have passed since her death. Beth has accordingly exhibited her mothers knack for unvarnished truths. Before their conversation, Beths behavior is timid and a far cry from the tough-as-nails, grown-up mean girl she is today. The brothers were angry with Beth for firing their father, so they set fire to the Dutton Ranchs barn. The matriarch of the family is John Dutton, who has only one biological son.